Empowering New State Health IT Leaders: Sharing Expertise Through State Health Technology Commons
By Kate Ricker and Amy Zimmerman
In 2009, when the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) was introduced, many of us were deeply immersed in state efforts to advance health information exchange (HIE). The Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) (now the Assistant Secretary for Technology Policy (ASTP)), announced the State Health Information Exchange Cooperative Agreement Program, offering states federal funding to expand HIE efforts. This funding presented a unique opportunity to bridge data and technology gaps across health systems.
Along with this funding came new responsibilities for states, including the State IT Coordinator role. Each state applying for funding was required to have a State Health IT Coordinator providing, “health IT leadership and coordination across the federally funded state programs, including supporting the efforts of the State Medicaid Directors (SMDs) in developing the state’s Medicaid Electronic Health Record Meaningful Use Incentive Program (now known as Promoting Interoperability.” In addition, State Health IT Coordinators coordinated health IT activities across Medicaid, behavioral health, public health, departments of aging, and other federally funded state programs. The role held responsibilities beyond the State HIE Program, including directing health technology policy, strategies, and activities across federal and state-funded programs advancing health data, interoperability, and technical capabilities.
Serving as State Health IT Coordinators in Colorado and Rhode Island, we took on this new and broader role as State Health IT Coordinators and became extremely busy focusing on our individual state efforts. It was challenging to keep up with national efforts and emerging health technology priorities. There were limited opportunities to engage the other State Health IT Coordinators for knowledge sharing beyond the initial State HIE Program. Almost 15 years later, states are no longer required to have a State Health IT Coordinator, but many states kept the role and expanded the role and teams responsible for this work. State governments still play a significant role in effectively and efficiently modernizing the overall health data ecosystem inclusive of health care delivery, public health, behavioral health, social care, and health insurance by having interoperable data networks.
Transitions and Evolution of Health Technology
The health technology landscape has undergone significant transformation over the past few decades, primarily driven by the increasing need for secure, efficient data sharing across the public and private health sectors. Since leaving our state government roles, we have witnessed the transition from CMS HITECH Federal Financial Participation (FFP) funding to Medicaid Enterprise Systems (MES) modular certification funding for HIE, a global pandemic emphasizing the need for standardized data reporting and robust data exchange, and the evolution of multi-sector data needs for behavioral health and social needs data.
The state health IT and informatics leaders today can be in different state agencies with a broad range of responsibilities, technology portfolios, and influence. This, in turn, requires a wide range of subject matter expertise. Stepping into the role of a state health IT leader can be both an exciting and overwhelming challenge with a steep learning curve.
State Health IT Leader example responsibilities: The complexities associated with establishing health IT strategies that promote interoperability among health information systems, navigating the federal and state regulatory landscape, aligning privacy laws and policies, leveraging existing infrastructure, harmonizing the implementation of data standards, securing and sustaining funding and driving innovation to support the use data for data driven decision making in a timely manner, requires a unique blend of relationship building and community engagement, collaboration, strategic visioning, general management and technical understanding.
We are committed to supporting new and existing state health IT leaders and providing them with specific opportunities to support and learn from each other. This is why we have partnered with Civitas Networks for Health to develop The State Health Technology Commons (the Commons). The Commons offers new and existing state health IT leaders an opportunity to build the expertise necessary for success and to continue expanding that knowledge throughout their careers.
The Journey to Becoming a State Health IT Leader
State health IT leaders are tasked with modernizing health information ecosystems to ensure that they are efficient, secure, and align with state and federal health care goals such as improving individual health and social outcomes, protecting public health, and ensuring equitable access to care. For those new to the role, topics such as understanding the intersection of policy and technology, maximizing the technology funding process and opportunities, leveraging HIEs and Health Data Utilities (HDUs) to increase interoperability, and assessing the impact of federal regulations can be intimidating.
This is where the State Health Technology Commons comes into play. Designed as a collaborative, open learning community, the Commons provides new as well as existing leaders with access to a wealth of resources, expert insights and experiences, and a supportive network of peers.
Michael Pancook has been serving as Maine’s Health Information Technology Coordinator for Maine’s Department of Health and Human Service since May 2023. Although Michael trained federally qualified health centers in the use of health it and data analysis, he found his new role a bit daunting. Michael, as a new state health IT leader has stated that participating in this learning community has “provided access to expertise and resources to manage the stream of new information and offered a safe venue to ask questions and share challenges.”
The journey for state health IT leaders is not typically a straight path. It is often a long and winding road with many twists and turns, and crossroads where decisions must be made. Today, we all use GPS to help us get to where we are going. The Commons is a tool, like GPS, that aids State Health IT Leaders in helping to navigate and drive efforts to meet state health IT needs in the following ways:
- Accelerating the Learning Curve - New state health IT leaders need to quickly get up to speed on a wide range of topics beyond technology such as community governance and partnerships, state and federal legal, regulatory and policy considerations, data and interoperability standards, and funding and sustainability to mention a few. The Commons provides an environment where newer leaders can promptly identify their peers in other states, talk with more experienced leaders and subject matter experts to better understand lessons learned and best practices, and ask questions to gain knowledge and obtain support, as needed. Accelerating the learning process can help new leaders avoid common pitfalls, build confidence, become educated and gain access to current resources to guide them in their work.
- Obtaining Mentorship and Peer Support - One of the most valuable aspects of the Commons is the opportunity for new leaders to connect with experienced mentors and peers. This often occurs during facilitated monthly calls. The relationships, built through the Commons, create a peer network where state leaders feel comfortable reaching out to others on their own to ask pressing questions, obtain guidance, and use each other as a sounding board or vent as needed. For many leaders, a peer support network is an essential resource that helps to reduce the feeling of job-related isolation and provides a safe and supportive environment. Collaboration and mentorship is not a one-way street. It fosters a culture of continuous learning and collaboration, where both new and season leaders benefit from the exchange of knowledge and perspectives.
- Enhancing Expertise Over Time - Health IT policies and tools are dynamic, ever-changing, and rapidly evolving. For state health IT leaders, staying current is a necessity. The Commons supports professional development and knowledge sharing by creating an environment that enables leaders to continuously expand their expertise. This includes the ability to stay current on new and emerging health IT topics (e.g., the use of AI), in addition to federal priorities and new initiatives.
- Creating a neutral and safe space in support of building ongoing state health IT leadership - The Commons strength is in facilitating a highly collaborative environment encouraging active and open participation. New and existing state leaders can engage in meaningful and honest conversations and learn from each other’s diverse perspectives and constraints. Creating a neutral and safe community with a shared purpose allows new leaders to comfortably ask questions, explore new concepts, gain feedback on their approaches, and create a common voice. For seasoned leaders, it offers the opportunity to contribute their knowledge and learn from the fresh perspectives of new leaders.
Looking Forward
The Commons serves as an investment in the future of state health IT leadership. As leaders continue to increase their understanding of state health IT needs and solutions, the overall capacity of state health ecosystems across the country will continue to expand and improve. The Commons offers a unique opportunity for state health IT leaders to obtain familiarity with their role and for all leaders, new or old, to expand their expertise in a caring and supportive, collaborative environment. We encourage all state health IT leaders to join the Commons. Together, we can build a stronger, more knowledgeable community of state health IT leaders prepared to address the rapidly evolving health IT needs of states and align with national efforts.
Kate Ricker, B.A., M.A., is a transformative leader in health policy, strategy, technology, and program integration with nineteen years of experience providing vision and successful execution of multi-stakeholder projects. She has advised thirty-two states leveraging a unique capacity to conceptualize and develop creative solutions to complex health initiatives in the public and private sectors.
Amy Zimmerman, MPH, is a health Information technology and exchange specialist focusing on state and federal strategy, policy, and operations.
We encourage you to get in touch with our team at Civitas to hear more about our work, our partners, and answer any questions you might have.
If you are interested in participating in the State Health Technology Commons, please reach out to
Learning the language of Health Information Exchange: Insights from Ohio Health Information Partnership’s Henry Vynalek
Bridging the gaps between technology, research, and patient care has been an invaluable translation skill for Henry Vynalek, Senior Director of Health Information Exchange (HIE) and IT Operations and Security Officer for CliniSync, of Ohio Health Information Partnership (OHIP). Henry’s decade-long journey with OHIP and his extensive background in health care provides a unique perspective on the evolving landscape of HIEs.
His journey from pharmacy technician to a key player in health care IT showcases a diverse skill set and an ability to adapt and thrive in various roles.
Speaking the Right Language
Henry’s roots in health care IT run deep but it’s his background that gave him the language he needed to blend his experience and expertise for success.
After working in various health care settings, including a pharmacy, a research lab, and the Ohio State Medical Center and Nationwide Children’s Hospital, Henry decided to try something new and find an intersection between his interests in health and computers.
What he developed was a deep understanding of how health data is collected, processed, and shared along with the skill set to address the technology-related barriers health care workers face when providing patient care and addressing health-related issues. With this backbone, Henry has been able to effectively communicate with end-users about their needs and translate those insights into product developments that make data processes more seamless with OHIP’s CliniSync.
OHIP operates on a stakeholder-driven model, engaging over 150 hospitals across Ohio. Recognizing the diversity of needs among acute care facilities, specialty hospitals, ACOs, ambulatory facilities, reference labs, state departments, and payers, OHIP fosters regional collaborations that bring together various health care providers to address common challenges and streamline data exchange processes.
One challenge where Henry’s translational skills were put to the test was the varying preferences among providers for accessing patient data. While a comprehensive continuity of care document (CCD) seemed like the best solution for CliniSync’s upgrade on paper, the emergency care providers Henry worked with expressed a need for more granular, on-demand access to specific data points. With this insight, OHIP reassessed CliniSync’s Community Health Record (CHR) offering, providing a new use case that allowed providers to choose the method that best suited their workflow, whether it's a comprehensive document via CCD query or detailed individual results via the CHR.
Collaborative Efforts for Forward-Looking, Accurate, Unified Data
OHIP’s success is built on collaboration. The organization works closely with a diverse range of stakeholders across Ohio to address common challenges and improve interoperability. Henry’s approach emphasizes cooperation over competition, recognizing that shared goals lead to better outcomes for all.
One critical focus for Henry is ensuring data quality at the lowest level. The accuracy of data input, especially concerning social determinants of health data, is necessary and mistakes/incorrect information can significantly impact the integrity of the entire dataset.
OHIP's strategy involves creating a stakeholder-led data committee to put shared robust systems and operations in place to facilitate correct data entry, minimize human error, and enhance data reliability.
This collaborative effort aims to ensure that the data driving health care decisions is reliable and comprehensive to ultimately enhance the quality and accessibility of patient data across Ohio.
As CliniSync continues to grow, plans are underway to transition to a more scalable, next-generation platform. Moving some components to the cloud will further enhance scalability, ensuring that OHIP can handle increasing data volumes and maintain high-performance levels.
Engaging with Civitas in Meaningful Ways
Henry’s forward-thinking approaches and commitment to continuous improvement are sure to support this next phase for OHIP and CliniSync. Rising leaders like Henry are critical to the overall success of Civitas’ work as well, where networking, professional development, and leadership growth is helping transform the field of health information technology and health improvement.
As an active member of Civitas participating in the Emerging Leaders Forum, Henry benefits from the collective knowledge and experience of HIEs across the country, which provides opportunities to influence industry standards and collaborate with peers, recognizing the diverse needs and priorities of different states.
This October, hundreds of health IT and health improvement leaders will join Civitas for its 2024 Annual Conference centered on, “Bridging Data and Doing,” in Detroit. “The Civitas conference grants HIEs a unique opportunity for collaboration and engagement, as well as providing a forum for all members to discuss and strategize the future of health care informatics,” says Henry. Along with other OHIP team members, Henry will be joining us in Detroit—Be sure to catch up with him in person!
Henry Vynalek is a seasoned health care technology leader with more than 15 years of experience connecting and analyzing health care data for major hospitals and health care facilities across Ohio. Henry serves as the Senior Director of Health Information Exchange (HIE) and IT Operations and Security Officer for CliniSync, of Ohio Health Information Partnership (OHIP). He is known for his structured yet innovative approach to problem-solving and effectively bridging technical and clinical gaps to deliver practical solutions that enhance data interoperability.
We encourage you to get in touch with our team at Civitas to hear more about our work, our partners, and answer any questions you might have.
Why CMS' Proposed New Advanced Primary Care Management Codes are a Big Deal: A Real Movement Forward for Whole-Person Health
By Diane Marriott and Alan Katz
Each July, CMS releases a proposed Physician Fee Schedule (PFS) that previews proposed changes to physician payment and other Medicare B services for the upcoming year. Last year, for example, CMS introduced the Community Health Integration and social determinants of health (SDoH) Risk Assessment codes and previewed them in the 2024 proposed rule. We are hopeful about the positive impact these changes can foster in our health system, promoting positive health outcomes and advancing whole-person health while simultaneously reducing barriers for service providers.
For Civitas members, one of the most interesting aspects of the 2025 PFS proposed rule is CMS’ introduction of three advanced primary care management (APCM) codes, which represent a first-of-its-kind attempt to “bundle” several different billable care coordination activities into single G-codes for use by Medicare primary care providers at large. The three proposed APCM codes vary by patient complexity and pay practices for advanced care management on a monthly basis, instead of paying piecemeal on a fee-for-service basis. This is a big move forward in providing practices with reliable revenue to meet the care coordination needs of their patients.
When Medicare introduces new codes, commercial plans, and Medicaid plans, other payers take note and often introduce them as billable codes, making it possible for practices to apply them across the range of payers they may work with.
Whether your organization interacts with primary care practices; helps to engage community resources to address social drivers of health; promotes the uses of patient-reported outcome tools; provides data; facilitates gaps in care reporting; or serves people with health and social needs, it helps to have strong primary care partners. Let’s look at the requirements for the proposed new APCM codes:
- Patient Consent: Inform the patient about the service, obtain consent, and document it in the medical record.
- Initiating Visit: Engage new patients or those not seen within three years.
- 24/7 Access: Provide patients with urgent care access to the care team/practitioner at all times.
- Continuity of Care: Ensure continuity with a designated team member for successive routine appointments.
- Alternative Care Delivery: Offer care through methods beyond traditional office visits, such as home visits and extended hours.
- Comprehensive Care Management:
- Conduct systematic needs assessments.
- Ensure receipt of preventive services.
- Manage medication reconciliation and oversight of self-management.
- Electronic Care Plan: Develop and maintain a comprehensive care plan accessible to the care team and patient.
- Care Transitions Coordination: Facilitate transitions between health care settings and providers, ensuring timely follow-up communication.
- Ongoing Communication: Coordinate with various service providers and document communications about the patient’s needs and preferences.
- Enhanced Communication Methods: Enable communication through secure messaging, email, patient portals, and other digital means.
- Population Data Analysis: Identify care gaps and offer additional interventions.
- Risk Stratification: Use data to identify and target services to high-risk patients.
- Performance Measurement: Assess quality of care, total cost of care, and use of Certified EHR Technology (CEHRT).
Practices need strong, inter-connected data systems to make this happen, and the APCM codes:
- Require the use of certified electronic health record (EHR) technology (CEHRT) and remote access to the care plan, a helpful step to ease the path to interoperability. In the proposed rule, CMS notes that CEHRT is, “fundamental to providing the APCM service elements of 24/7 Access to Care, Continuity of Care, and Management of Care Transitions under an advanced primary care delivery model.” By requiring CEHRT, CMS is encouraging practices to electronically report clinical quality, support data exchange with other providers and health systems, and connect to their regional health information exchange (HIE).
- Provide practices with resources to support patient care optimization and prevent things from slipping through the cracks in transitions of care from an emergency department (ED) or hospital to make sure that patient needs are met. This includes medications being reconciled and following up with patients —either virtually or in-person—in the prescribed timeframes. You can’t do this without information and data exchange about patients seen in an ED or admitted to/discharged from a hospital (for example, via HIE, hospital portal, hospital-generated report, EHR, or additional health IT system); and
- Put practices on track to Medicare Value Pathway reporting and electronic clinical quality measures (eCQMs).
What could these new codes mean for population health? Looking at states like Michigan that have had experience with CMMI multi-payer models, including APCM-like payments (e.g., multi-payer advanced primary care practice (MAPCP) and Primary Care First (PCF)), might give us a glimpse. Until now, to receive this kind of monthly advanced primary care management funding for their Medicare patients, a primary care practice had to be fortunate enough to qualify for a spot in a Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) advanced primary care innovation model with enough other participating payers to cover most of the patients in their panel. When the innovation model ceased, so did the Medicare per member per month (PMPM) funding for advanced primary care management. Even if the commercial payers were able to continue funding, the loss of Medicare and Medicaid funding was often so significant that it was a non-starter for many. It’s margin versus mission, again. The introduction of APCM codes will be a game-changer for these practices.
Introducing APCM codes, however, is not a silver bullet. There are some aspects of the proposed APCM rule that are less than ideal (the payment rate, the potential for the 10% of Traditional Medicare beneficiaries who do not have Medigap to face the statutory 20% cost share, etc.). CMS would probably have addressed these if it had the authority to do so.
Let’s not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. There is much that CMS has enabled in the new APCM codes that can unveil a new age of true care integration and coordination.
In the proposed 2025 PFS rule, CMS has included an extensive RFI section focused on the new APCM code set and future value-based reimbursement models more broadly. Civitas Networks for Health, a national nonprofit collaborative representing over 170 member organizations that are advancing health data exchange and health improvement throughout the U.S. has the ability to bring forward critical perspectives from implementers using data-led multi-stakeholder approaches to both payment and deliver reform. Civitas will speak to the challenges and opportunities created for many of its members’ public comments on the proposed rule, as well as in ongoing communications with regulatory bodies and policymakers to ensure that they understand our perspectives. Civitas will also continue to highlight the technical and operational aspects of value-based care approaches and share best practices among members through its workgroups, collaborative sessions and other forums, such as the Government Relations and Advocacy Council (GRAC).
Our field is ready to move forward with these opportunities CMS is offering to provide better care and promote better health outcomes. We look forward to the next steps and working with fellow Civitas members to implement these critical changes!
Diane Bechel Marriott, DrPH, MHSA, directs Michigan Multipayer Initiatives (MMI), a group that catalyzes health care payer and plan alignment on common, evidence-based policy to improve health equity, quality of care, patient experience, affordability of care, and the health of the populations served.
Based at the University of Michigan and hosted by the Center for Healthcare Research and Transformation, MMI also works with providers, practices, physician organizations, social care organizations, national groups, and patients to ensure that community voice is incorporated.
Diane has served as Statewide Convener for several large-scale CMMI primary care practice demonstrations to improve value, quality, and patient/provider experience outcomes including Comprehensive Primary Care Plus (CPC+), Michigan Primary Care Transformation (MiPCT), and the Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH) Initiatives of Michigan’s State Innovation Model (SIM). She is also a member of the Milbank Fund’s Multipayer Primary Care Network Advisory Group and has served on committees for the National Quality Forum, U.S. Preventive Task Force, National Business Group on Health, and E-Health Initiative.
Alan Katz is Associate Director of Advocacy and Public Policy at Civitas Networks for Health, working to continue shaping the future of health improvement and information exchange through government relations in Washington D.C., and beyond. Alan brings over a decade of experience representing public and private entities before policymakers, including acute and specialty health care providers ranging from Fortune 500 systems to Critical Access Hospitals that have successfully leveraged data partnerships to improve access and efficiency in some of the nation’s most underserved communities.
We encourage you to get in touch with our team at Civitas to hear more about our work, our partners, and answer any questions you might have.
Collaboratives in Action: Data-Driven Partnerships - SHARE HIE & Community Quality Alliance Leading the Way in Collaborative Health Care Transformation
Collaboratives in Action: Building on Existing Infrastructure to Further Health Related Social Needs Screening
Thank you to all who attended our Collaboratives in Action event on August 29. During the event, our presenters shared insight into the transformative shift in health care facilitated by a strategic partnership between Arkansas State Health Alliance for Records Exchange (SHARE) and Community Quality Alliance (CQA) clinically integrated network (CIN). This presentation featured discussions from:
- Justin Villines, MBA, BSM | Health Information Technology Policy Director, Arkansas Department of Health – Office of Health Information Technology, State Health Alliance for Records Exchange (SHARE)
- Britni Hoyt, MPH, MBA | Director of Quality Operations and Care Management, Northwest Health System
Partner Press Release | Supporting Health Data Modernization: A Collaborative Effort
Civitas Networks for Health is thrilled to be partnering with Guidehouse to support state and local health agencies working to advance public health infrastructure through the Data Modernization Implementation Center Program.
As a leading global provider of strategy and managed services to commercial and public sector clients, Guidehouse has been selected by the Public Health Infrastructure Partners as one of three Implementation Centers to provide direct technical assistance to public health agencies in their data modernization efforts. Civitas will be partnering directly with Guidehouse to provide subject matter expertise and to facilitate connections across our diverse network of health information exchanges and implementation partners. Civitas is dedicated to fostering robust health data systems that enhance the capacity of public health agencies to respond effectively to health challenges. This partnership underscores our commitment to improving public health infrastructure, ensuring that communities across the nation benefit from advanced, resilient, and efficient health data systems.
Civitas also acknowledges other members and partners awarded to lead Implementation centers — CRISP Shared Services (CSS) has also been selected to as an Implementation Center, in partnership with Innsena, and others. The third Center will be led by Mathematica, a research and data analytics consultancy.
Read the full Guidehouse press release here
Read the CRISP Shared Services press release here
Civitas Networks for Health Releases Agenda for the 2024 Annual Conference
National Coordinator for Health Information Technology and Acting Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Ernest A. Sharpe Centennial Professor and Executive Director of the IC2 Institute at the University of Texas at Austin, Founder of Enlightening Results and Co-Founder of Unblock Health, and CEO of the Digital Medicine Society join as Keynote Speakers at the 2024 Civitas Networks for Health Annual Conference in Detroit.
Today, Civitas Networks for Health (Civitas) released its 2024 Annual Conference agenda centered around the theme, “Bridging Data and Doing.” Featured in this programming is a newly announced Keynote Panel on artificial intelligence (AI) governance in health and health care highlighting Micky Tripathi, National Coordinator for Health Information Technology and Acting Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; S. Craig Watkins, Ernest A. Sharpe Centennial Professor and Executive Director of the IC2 Institute at the University of Texas at Austin; Grace Cordovano, Founder of Enlightening Results and Co-Founder of Unblock Health; and Jennifer Goldsack, CEO of the Digital Medicine Society. Lisa Bari, MBA, MPH, CEO of Civitas, will serve as moderator for this innovative session.
Micky Tripathi, National Coordinator for Health Information Technology and Acting Chief Artificial Intelligence Officer of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Micky Tripathi, Ph.D., MPP, brings more than 20 years of experience in the health IT landscape to his role leading federal health IT strategy, policies, standards, programs, and investments. His extensive background, including leadership roles in health data management and policy, will provide a wealth of knowledge on the future directions of health information technology.
S. Craig Watkins, Ernest A. Sharpe Centennial Professor and Executive Director, IC2 Institute at the University of Texas at Austin
Craig Watkins’, Ph.D., research focuses on the role of AI in addressing health and well-being disparities. As principal investigator for the Good Systems Grand Challenge and a National Institutes of Health-funded project, he explores the design and deployment of ethical AI design, particularly in Health AI. His extensive background and commitment to inclusive ethical AI development is sure to be insightful.
Grace Cordovano, Founder of Enlightening Results and Co-Founder of Unblock Health
Grace Cordovano, Ph.D., BCPA, is an internationally recognized expert in patient navigation and informed decision-making in cancer and medically complex care. With more than 25 years of experience, she is a champion for harnessing the power of digital health and AI to help patients and their families operationalize the care they need and reduce their patient administrative burden. Her insights into increasing transparency, building trust, addressing disparities, and empowering patients while amplifying patient and care partner voices are sure to provide valuable takeaways.
Jennifer Goldsack, CEO of the Digital Medicine Society
Jennifer Goldsack’s, MChem, M.A., MBA, OLY, work focuses on advancing the use of digital medicine to promote safety, effectiveness, and equitability in health, health care, and health research. She serves on the Board of Directors of the Coalition for Health AI (CHAI™). Her insights on supporting professionals at the intersection of health care and technology through interdisciplinary collaboration, treatment, and education of evidence-based practices will offer practical takeaways for implementation.
These experts join previously announced Keynote speakers, Roselyn Tso, B.A., M.A., Director of the Indian Health Service; Meena Seshamani, M.D., Ph.D., Deputy Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and Director of the Center for Medicare; Michigan State Lieutenant Governor Garlin Gilchrist II, BSE; and Ninah Sasy, B.S., M.S., MPH, Policy and Planning Director, Michigan Department of Health and Human Services.
This year, Civitas’ member-led Proposal Selection Committee received 150+ proposals, showcasing many compelling presentation topics and innovative ideas. After an intensive review process, Civitas is pleased to bring forward an excellent lineup of presentations and deliver informative, engaging, and innovative sessions geared toward implementers working on improving data interoperability and health in our country.
The full agenda can be viewed here.
The 2024 Civitas Annual Conference, in collaboration with Upper Midwest Region Members, will take place in Detroit, Michigan, from Tuesday, October 15, to Thursday, October 17, 2024. The theme for this year’s conference, “Bridging Data and Doing,” will explore critical topics such as expanding health data sharing, fostering promising partnerships, and developing community-centered approaches to address health-related social needs. This is a premier event for health industry leaders, professionals, and innovators. Attendees will have the opportunity to engage with experts, participate in interactive sessions, and network with peers and businesses dedicated to advancing health data sharing and community health initiatives.
This event is supported by Platinum Sponsor InterSystems, and Upgrade and Silver Sponsors Comagine Health, Contexture, Delaware Health Information Network (DHIN), Health Roads, KPI Ninja by Health Catalyst, NinePatch, Inc., PointClickCare, Secure Exchange Solutions, Selfiie, Inc., Telligen, and Velatura.
Register for the Conference: https://civitasforhealth.swoogo.com/civitas2024
Media contact:
Radhika Hira
Senior Communications and Marketing Manager, Civitas Networks for Health
Advancing Health-Related Social Needs Screening through Health Information Exchange Infrastructure and Data Standardization
By Jolie Ritzo and Jessica Little
Addressing health-related social needs (HRSNs) is crucial to ensure the best health outcomes, improve treatment, and increase care coordination between community and health care settings. Data derived from HRSN screening also informs health care and public health processes such as payment, quality, and population health, and can also influence policies and programs to support the health of communities and individuals.
By leveraging existing data infrastructure from health information exchanges (HIEs) and standardizing how data is coded and exchanged we can transform data derived from HRSN screening into a meaningful resource that benefits patients, providers, and communities, which ultimately supports whole-person health.
Standardizing Data Collection and Exchange
Collecting HRSN screening data within various care settings—social services, community-based organizations, and health care—is the first step toward progress. However, to ensure the best patient experience and lack of duplication, it is important that this data can be shared across settings. This critical aspect lies in standardizing this data for interoperable use and integration into existing processes and tools.
Health-related social needs (HRSNs) refer to individual-level factors, whereas social determinants of health (SDOH) refer to community-level factors, both of which impact an individual’s health and well-being, according to HHS.gov.
Social determinants of health (SDOH) are the conditions in the environments where people are born, live, learn, work, play, worship, and age that affect a wide range of health, functioning, and quality-of-life outcomes and risks, according to health.gov.
Computers cannot interpret responses to HRSN screening questions without a standardized coding system. Data standards can allow for the seamless exchange of electronic codes between unaffiliated providers and disconnected care settings to enable whole-person care. That’s where the Gravity Project ® comes in.
The Gravity Project is a consensus-driven collaborative that leads the development and implementation of SDOH data standards. Gravity supports four clinical activities: screenings, assessment and diagnosis, goal setting, and treatment interventions. Information can be accurately captured and exchanged to advance interoperability by using validated screening tools and standardized coding for HRSN screening data, such as those found in different code sets utilized for clinical activities.
Civitas Networks for Health – A Gravity Implementation Partner
The Gravity Project operates three work streams: terminology, technology, and implementation. Terminology develops languages and codes created through an evidence-based consensus-building process designed to make data publicly available for exchange. The technical workstream addresses how these codes are exchanged, aiming for advancements like Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR) ®. And the implementation workstream advances the adoption of SDOH data standards by meeting communities where they are and providing forums and resources supporting implementation activities.
Civitas Networks for Health (Civitas) is a national nonprofit member and mission-driven organization focused on health data exchange and health improvement; it acts as a bridge between data and doing. As a member and partner of Gravity, Civitas works to support implementation of Gravity data standards in communities throughout states and regions by engaging its members and their partners, connecting them with Gravity experts and resources. Through convening partners, experts, and community members, Civitas supports pilots and peer-to-peer learning forums where implementers can learn from the successes and challenges of others implementing HRSN screenings and standardizing data exchange, allowing members to build upon progress generated by others.
At Civitas’ recent May Collaboratives in Action event, we heard directly from members of the Civitas network leading implementation efforts to embed HRSN screening data in clinical settings within the contexts of their unique state, local, and community perspectives. They shared successes, barriers, and outcomes of their work to provide highly relevant insights that allow others to learn from their journeys.
MyHealth Access Network (MyHealth)
MyHealth Access Network, a nonprofit HIE in Oklahoma, has been addressing SDOH by integrating HRSN screening and referrals into clinical care settings. Having been awarded an Accountable Health Communities (AHC) model grant in 2016, MyHealth embarked on an innovative journey to bridge clinical data with social services, recognizing the fragmented nature of both clinical and HRSN data. The effort led to the creation of the Route 66 Consortium, which united competing communities and established the governance and relationship-building essential for collaboration. Through its role as a state-designated HIE, MyHealth leveraged its data infrastructure to implement a comprehensive social needs screening process, seamlessly integrating HRSN data into clinical workflows and facilitating timely referrals to community resources.
MyHealth developed a workflow that utilized mobile technology to conduct screenings and deliver referral information in real-time, effectively automating the process. This modern approach ensured high screening and response rates while also showing significant reductions in health care costs and provider burden. By May 2024, MyHealth had offered more than 4.5 million screenings, identified and addressed nearly a million social needs, and saved an estimated 250,000 hours of staff effort, roughly equating to $4.5 million in savings. This model showcases the role HIEs can provide in integrating SDOH considerations into clinical care, ultimately improving patient outcomes and enhancing the efficiency of health care delivery.
North Carolina Health Information Exchange Authority (NC HealthConnex) and North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services
North Carolina's Department of Health and Human Services (NCDHHS) partnered with their state-wide HIE, NC HealthConnex, to improve the exchange of data related to HRSNs within its Medicaid program. NCDHHS aimed to create interoperable data systems that provide necessary, relevant patient data to inform clinical decision-making and provide the best care. By implementing pilots under the 1115 waiver, NCDHHS pioneered a program that allowed community-based organizations to invoice for non-medical interventions and ensure that HRSN screening data was collected. These pilots were geographically limited but aimed to provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of addressing HRSNs through community-based efforts.
To advance similar goals, North Carolina began integrating HRSN screening data from various health systems into NC HealthConnex, creating a unified system that facilitates data sharing. The initial pilot phase involved collaboration with the NCDHHS and selected health care organizations to standardize data collection using LOINC codes and CCD-10 codes. The first phase of this work successfully identified commonalities and variations in screening questions, paving the way for standardized data entry. Moving forward, the state plans to expand the pilot to include primary care practices and Medicaid health plans, aiming to ensure comprehensive data flow from providers' electronic health records into NC HealthConnex. The goal is to use this data for improved clinical decision-making, policy development, and program evaluation, with a future focus on incorporating referral and intervention data to address identified needs more effectively.
Challenges and the Path Forward
By identifying the needs of individuals and communities, and where there are unmet HRSNs, we can better inform and shape programs and policies that address needs, thereby promoting health equity and overall well-being.
Despite many successes with HRSN screening and standardized data exchange, challenges remain, such as variability in screening tools as well as the associated time and financial costs of standardization. Resources are needed to develop consistent, interoperable rules for validated screening tools and to support the iterative process of building, implementing, learning, and refining these standards. There is also a tremendous need for education and furthering the adoption of existing resources, standards, and tools.
Clarity and appropriate funding for entities responsible for collecting, coding, and exchanging this data are also critical. Different states have varying responsibilities and resources for these tasks, necessitating a collaborative and localized approach to ensure efficiency and effectiveness.
Advancing HRSN screening, data capture and exchange through use of existing HIE infrastructure, and adopted standards is a collaborative and continuous effort that Civitas is supporting through multiple fronts. Civitas is also closely tracking partnerships between CIEs and HIEs, which brings great promise in having more connected and streamlined data across sectors. By utilizing tools, such as those from the Gravity Project, and supporting local implementation, we can improve data exchange, reduce provider and patient burdens, and ultimately enhance health outcomes. This process not only supports whole-person health but also strengthens the foundation for a more equitable and effective health care system.
Jolie Ritzo is Vice President of Strategy and Network Engagement at Civitas Networks for Health. She leads communications and marketing, government relations and advocacy, event strategy, and strategic planning. Jolie previously served as the Director of Partnerships and Programs at the Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement (NRHI). Jolie also serves as President of the Crossroads Board of Directors, a nonprofit organization serving patients and families in Maine with addiction and behavioral health treatment.
Jessica Little is Vice President of Business Development and Programs at Civitas Networks for Health. Jessica oversees Civitas’ portfolio of grant-funded programs and contracts and leads the development of strategic partnerships with funders and program partners. Jessica also serves on the Gravity Project Operating Committee and a variety of other national workgroups aimed at improving health and social care data interoperability.
We encourage you to get in touch with our team at Civitas to hear more about our work, our partners, and answer any questions you might have.
Civitas Networks for Health Announces Three New Keynote Speakers for the 2024 Annual Conference
Deputy Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and Director of the Center for Medicare, Michigan State Lieutenant Governor, and Michigan Department of Health and Human Services Policy and Planning Director will join the Director of the Indian Health Service as Keynote Speakers at the 2024 Civitas Networks for Health Annual Conference in Detroit.
Civitas Networks for Health is pleased to announce the addition of three distinguished speakers to present at its 2024 Annual Conference. Meena Seshamani, Deputy Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and Director of the Center for Medicare, will deliver a keynote address focused on progress with value-based care and the importance of multi-stakeholder data-driven approaches to furthering this imperative work. We’ll also kick off the conference with a panel discussion on collective efforts to advance state-wide social care with Michigan State Lieutenant Governor Garlin Gilchrist II and Ninah Sasy, Policy and Planning Director of the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, which will be moderated by Phillip Levy, M.D., MPH, Professor of Emergency Medicine and Associate Vice President for Translational Science at Wayne State University and Director of the Michigan Mobile Health Corps.
Meena Seshamani, Deputy Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and Director of the Center for Medicare
Meena Seshamani, M.D., Ph.D., is a strategic leader with expertise in health economics, health policy, and patient care. Her leadership at the CMS has been crucial in the ongoing efforts to enhance health care delivery and accessibility. Her perspective will offer relevant insights into strategizing for value-based health care.
Michigan State Lieutenant Governor Garlin Gilchrist II
Lt. Governor Gilchrist, BSE, has been a pivotal figure in advancing technological and community initiatives across the state to build a more just, equitable, prosperous, and connected Michigan. His insight into policies advancing data-driven health is sure to be enlightening.
Ninah Sasy, Policy and Planning Director, Michigan Department of Health and Human Services
Ninah Sasy, B.S. M.S., MPH, brings extensive experience in continuous health quality improvement. Her work has been instrumental in shaping health initiatives that prioritize community needs centered around equity and infrastructure. Her expertise in creating, executing, and assessing state-wide social determinants of health strategy is sure to offer valuable takeaways.
These experts join previously announced keynote speaker Roselyn Tso, B.A., M.A., Director of the Indian Health Service (IHS), who will speak to IHS’ data modernization priorities, tribal outreach, and coordination on health and health care issues unique to tribal nations.
The 2024 Civitas Annual Conference will take place in Detroit, Michigan, from Tuesday, October 15 to Thursday, October 17, 2024. The theme for this year’s conference, “Bridging Data and Doing,” will explore critical topics such as expanding health data sharing, fostering promising partnerships, and developing community-centered approaches to address health-related social needs.
The Civitas Annual Conference is a premier event for health industry leaders, professionals, and innovators. Attendees will have the opportunity to engage with experts, participate in interactive sessions, and network with peers and businesses dedicated to advancing health data sharing and community health initiatives. With more than 150 submissions for speaking proposals, the anticipated agenda, due for release in July, stands to deliver informative, engaging, and innovative sessions geared toward implementers working on improving data interoperability and health in our country.
Register here: https://civitasforhealth.swoogo.com/civitas2024
Media contact:
Radhika Hira
Senior Communications and Marketing Manager, Civitas Networks for Health
Civitas Networks for Health in Partnership with Gravity Project® Announces Four New Pilot Sites to Further Implementation of SDOH Data Standards
Civitas Networks for Health in Partnership with Gravity Project® Announces Four New Pilot Sites to Further Implementation of SDOH Data Standards
Civitas Networks for Health in Partnership with Gravity Project® Announces Four New Pilot Sites to Further Implementation of SDOH Data Standards
Early stage highly collaborative pilots work to further SDOH data exchange for advancement of public health priorities and health equity.
Washington, DC – April 11, 2023 – Civitas Networks for Health, in partnership with Gravity Project, and with funding from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, announced the selection of four new early-stage pilot projects addressing public health and/or health equity use cases. This is a critical milestone in expanding SDOH data standards use in communities, which is a necessary step in building health equity infrastructure.
The purpose of this initiative is to improve accessibility, knowledge, and capabilities for exchange of Gravity terminology standards with a focus on public health and health equity use cases; strengthen capacity for viable, cross-sector data sharing partnerships; and increase communication and collaboration for coordinating health and social care services among integral parties such as health care payers, providers, patients, community members, vendors, public health, health information exchanges, and community-based health and social services.
“There is tremendous need to support communities with the adoption and use of data standards so that we can more seamlessly address both patients’ and communities’ unmet social needs toward the goal of health equity. Our next phase of pilots will find us working in and with communities and their diverse stakeholders in order to support collection and exchange of community-led and community-governed standardized social care data.” Notes Dr. Sarah DeSilvey, Terminology Director for the Gravity Project.
The following four cross-sector teams will begin piloting Gravity Project SDOH standards this April:
Pima County/Southwest Tribe: Pima County and a Southwest Tribe aim to initiate data exchange between the county and tribe within the State communicable disease surveillance system in order to support the tribe in obtaining data to inform procedures and policies that promote the health of the tribal community.
MyHealth Access Network: MyHealth aims to offer standardized screening and referral for social needs at every site of care in Oklahoma using Gravity-vetted terminology. By evaluating and planning for additional needs based on standardized data, MyHealth and its multisectoral partners can dramatically improve the health equity and utilization of the screening across sectors.
University of Colorado Hospital: University of Colorado Hospital and its partners aim to improve the capture of social risk data, develop an equitable approach to resource referral delivery to address patients’ unmet needs, and optimize the capacity of limited care management staff while expanding access to resources for patients. This data will also be used to inform the UCH community needs assessment to identify patient catchment areas with high social needs.
Bronx RHIO: The six NYS certified Health Information Exchanges (also known as Qualified Entities) and the New York eHealth Collaborative (NYeC) are working together to implement statewide standards for the ingestion and handling of social risk data. During this process, the group, also known as the Statewide Health Information Network for NY (SHIN-NY) is planning to use Gravity Project terminology and coding standards to ensure consistent handling of social risk data across the state.
The four new pilot teams will receive one-to-one technical assistance and also participate in a learning community that allows for shared learning across the sites. The Gravity Project team and their extensive community of practice will be accessible to pilot teams as subject matter experts in Gravity deliverables, social care data standards and social care interoperability. Civitas has expertise in building and supporting multi-site learning communities, increasing capacity for technical assistance, furthering implementation efforts, and bi-directional exchange of communication between regional and national partners.
Learn more about The Gravity Project Pilots Affinity Group on confluence
###
About Civitas Networks for Health
Civitas Networks for Health is a national collaborative comprised of member organizations working to use health information exchange, health data, and multi-stakeholder, cross-sector approaches to improve health. Civitas was previously known as the Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement and the Strategic Health Information Exchange Collaborative, and today represents more than 160 member organizations and business partners moving and using data to improve health outcomes across the U.S. Civitas educates, promotes, and influences both the private sector and federal and state policymakers on matters of interoperability, quality, coordination, health equity, and cost-effectiveness of health care. Working with healthcare and public health innovators at the state and local levels, Civitas facilitates the exchange of valuable resources, tools, and ideas—and offers a national perspective on upcoming standards and regulations, emerging technologies, and best practices.
For more information, visit https://www.civitasforhealth.org.
About Gravity Project
The Gravity Project is a multi-stakeholder public collaborative from across the health and human services ecosystem focused on developing, testing, and validating standardized data to address the social determinants of health for use in patient care, care coordination between health and human services sectors, population health management, public health, value-based payment, and clinical research. The Gravity Project has grown into a leading multidisciplinary community of 2,500+ participants that has successfully introduced a nationally recognized set of open data standards-based terminologies to support care across 17 social risk domains and a complete closed loop referral HL7 FHIR-based Implementation Guide. Gravity continues to advance its mission by leveraging its core standards to address national healthcare interoperability priorities related to social care delivery and quality reporting.
Learn more about The Gravity Project on confluence and on thegravityproject.net.
Civitas Networks for Health and Maryland Health Care Commission Release their Health Data Utility Framework
Civitas Networks for Health and Maryland Health Care Commission Release their Health Data Utility Framework
Civitas Networks for Health and Maryland Health Care Commission Release their Health Data Utility Framework
Action-oriented, research-based, and expert-informed framework developed to define and support stakeholders in the implementation of Health Data Utilities
Washington, DC – March 27, 2023 – Civitas Networks for Health, a national collaborative comprised of more than 160 member organizations working to use health information exchange (HIE), health data, and multistakeholder, cross-sector approaches to improve health, today released their Health Data Utility (HDU) Framework, developed in collaboration with the Maryland Health Care Commission (MHCC).
The HDU Framework is intended to guide states, regions, HIEs, and community partners in the design and implementation of an HDU that provides deeper integration of health-related data to support public health and care delivery.
“There is tremendous promise with HDU models to further interoperability efforts, advance health equity, and more effectively support whole-person care delivery by providing key stakeholders with the most comprehensive health data they need to make informed and proactive decisions,” said Lisa Bari, CEO of Civitas Networks for Health.
HDUs represent a new paradigm to support multi-stakeholder, cross-sector needs by serving as a data resource for use cases beyond clinical care delivery through multi-directional exchange. Information on this evolving landscape and drivers for emerging HDUs is included in Civitas and MHCC’s Advancing Implementation of Health Data Utility Models Issue Brief which was released in late 2022.
HDUs are models with cooperative leadership, designated authority, and advanced technical capabilities to combine, enhance, and exchange electronic health data across care and service settings for treatment, care coordination, quality improvement, and community and public health purposes. They leverage existing infrastructure through collaboration with state and regional HIEs.
“Health Data Utilities not only bring forward richer health data sets, but they ensure the most complete data privacy and security protections are upheld in the process. This is the result of utilizing existing infrastructure, trusted relationships, and deep knowledge of local regulations,” stated Craig Behm, CEO of the Chesapeake Regional Information System for Our Patients (CRISP) in Maryland and National Advisor of the Health Data Utility Framework.
Civitas is committed to continuing to advance the health information exchange and health improvement industry and sees the publication of the HDU Framework as a critical milestone. The interactive Framework can be found on the Civitas website, and there is also a downloadable pdf available. The goal is for the Framework to assist collaborators and entities within states in assessing their current readiness level, identifying next steps, and actioning or furthering implementation.
Earlier this month, Civitas officially opened registration for the Civitas Networks for Health 2023 Annual Conference, in Partnership with Chesapeake Bay Region Members. The conference will take place from August 20 through 23, at the Gaylord National Resort and Convention Center in National Harbor, Md. The theme for the conference is Public-Private Partnerships that Inspire Health Transformation. Civitas will continue to explore HDU models at the event as we dive deeper into the program tracks aligned with the theme.
Three industry thought leaders were announced as keynote speakers for the event. CEO of the CDC Foundation, Judith Monroe, MD, CEO of the deBeaumont Foundation, Brian Castrucci, DrPH, MA, and Chief Medical Officer of the Alaska Department of Health and President of ASTHO, Anne Zink, MD, will all join the conference as in-person keynote speakers. Additional keynote speakers will be announced in the coming weeks.
Early bird registration rates are offered through May 31, and the call for proposal for the conference is currently open through the month of March. For more information about the annual conference, visit civitasforhealth.org/2023-annual-conference.
###
About Civitas Networks for Health
Civitas Networks for Health is a national collaborative comprised of member organizations working to use health information exchange, health data, and multi-stakeholder, cross-sector approaches to improve health. Civitas was previously known as the Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement and the Strategic Health Information Exchange Collaborative, and today represents more than 160 member organizations and business partners moving and using data to improve health outcomes across the U.S. Civitas educates, promotes, and influences both the private sector and federal and state policymakers on matters of interoperability, quality, coordination, health equity, and cost-effectiveness of health care. Working with healthcare and public health innovators at the state and local levels, Civitas facilitates the exchange of valuable resources, tools, and ideas—and offers a national perspective on upcoming standards and regulations, emerging technologies, and best practices.
For more information, visit https://www.civitasforhealth.org/
About the Maryland Health Care Commission
The Maryland Health Care Commission is an independent regulatory agency whose mission is to plan for health system needs, promote informed decision-making, increase accountability, and improve access in a rapidly changing health care environment by providing timely and accurate information on availability, cost, and quality of services to policy makers, purchasers, providers and the public. The Commission’s vision for Maryland is to ensure that informed consumers hold the health care system accountable and have access to affordable and appropriate health care services through programs that serve as models for the nation.
For more information, visit https://mhcc.maryland.gov/.