Save the Date for the 2027 Annual Conference – September 27-29, 2027, St. Louis, Missouri

Measuring What Matters: Emerging Approaches to Data Quality Across the Civitas Network

Executive Summary

Health data organizations have spent years expanding connectivity and interoperability. Today, many are focused on a different challenge: ensuring the health data moving across their networks is complete, accurate, standardized, and actionable.

Across the Civitas Networks for Health® membership, organizations are advancing data quality as a strategic priority to support care coordination, quality measurement, value-based care, public health reporting, and emerging artificial intelligence applications. While each organization’s approach reflects its unique market and infrastructure, common themes are emerging around governance, standards, monitoring, collaboration, and accountability.

This case study highlights the work of three Health Information Exchange (HIE) organizations – Big Sky Care Connect (Montana), SYNCRONYS (New Mexico), and Healthix (New York) – as they build frameworks for measuring, improving, and sustaining high-quality data exchange.

The Shift from Connectivity to Data Quality

For many health data organizations, interoperability is no longer simply about moving data from one system to another. Today, the focus has shifted to questions such as:

  • Is the data complete?
  • Is it standardized?
  • Can clinicians trust it?
  • Can it support quality measurement?
  • Is it fit for analytics and AI applications?
  • How do organizations measure and improve quality over time?

For organizations like Big Sky Care Connect, SYNCRONYS, and Healthix, answering these questions has become a strategic priority.

Creating Meaningful Measures of Data Quality

One of the biggest challenges facing health data organizations is defining what “good” data actually looks like.

Big Sky Care Connect is working with vendor partners and stakeholders to establish standardized quality rubrics that can be used to measure incoming and outgoing data. Efforts include developing frameworks aligned with standards and use cases such as United States Core Data for Interoperability (USCDI), Patient Information Quality Improvement (PIQI), Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) measures, and Medicaid quality programs.

Rather than building tools first, the organization emphasizes starting with intended use cases and stakeholder value.

Define the quality rubrics and data use cases you are targeting before developing tools. Match the tools to the use cases and the value of the data.

Similarly, both SYNCRONYS and Healthix have focused on aligning data quality efforts with national interoperability initiatives and standards, including USCDI and NCQA’s Data Aggregator Validation (DAV) program.

RELATED READING

SYNCRONYS Is Among Latest to Earn Validated Data Stream Designation in NCQA Data Aggregator Validation Program

Governance as the Foundation

Across all three organizations, governance emerged as a critical success factor.

SYNCRONYS has established onboarding quality performance standards and thresholds governed through its Quality Governance Council. Requirements are tailored to different care settings, recognizing that hospitals, behavioral health providers, ambulatory practices, and laboratories may contribute different types of data while still meeting quality expectations.

Healthix likewise views data quality as an enterprise-wide responsibility supported by governance bodies, including its Clinical Committee. Through collaboration with funders, participants, and stakeholders, Healthix establishes priorities, validates improvement efforts, and reinforces accountability.

In discussing this work with all organizations, they alstated that grounded governance helps move data quality beyond a technical initiative and into an operational discipline supported across the organization.

Moving from Manual Reviews to Continuous Monitoring

Historically, many organizations relied on manual processes to identify data quality issues. Today, members are increasingly investing in automation, dashboards, scorecards, and advanced analytics.

SYNCRONYS has implemented multiple layers of monitoring and assessment, including:

  • Site-level data quality scorecards
  • Data quality dashboards
  • Data traffic monitoring
  • Specification validation against HL7 and C-CDA standards
  • Analysis of key fields and coding standards
  • Automated assessment of structural and semantic variances

Healthix has similarly invested in automated dashboards, alerts, and reporting mechanisms that enable continuous monitoring while providing feedback directly to participating organizations.

At Big Sky Care Connect, current pilot efforts are focused on creating measurement and reporting tools capable of assessing data entering the platform and evaluating the quality of structured data distributed to stakeholders.

Together, these efforts reflect a broader trend toward continuous, scalable monitoring that can identify issues earlier and support ongoing improvement.

Improving Patient Matching and Data Integrity

Another common priority involves strengthening patient identity management.

SYNCRONYS has focused significant effort on reducing Enterprise Master Patient Index (EMPI) duplication rates by improving matching performance and implementing stronger patient identity management processes.

Duplicate records often indicate larger downstream data quality challenges and can negatively affect clinical workflows, reporting, and patient care.

Healthix similarly identifies patient identity resolution as a key future priority as interoperability use cases become increasingly sophisticated.

These experiences highlight the importance of viewing patient matching as a foundational component of overall data quality.

Demonstrating Impact

While data quality work is often ongoing, organizations are already seeing measurable results.

Healthix reported:

  • NCQA Data Aggregator Validation (DAV) certification for 2026-2027
  • Data conformance and completeness rates exceeding 90%
  • A 35-45% improvement in ICD-10 conformance through collaboration with a major hospital system

SYNCRONYS reported:

  • Improved clinical data completeness
  • Reduced EMPI duplication rates
  • Increased visibility through dashboards and reporting tools
  • Greater clinician confidence in shared data

Big Sky Care Connect is currently building the infrastructure and measurement frameworks needed to evaluate future outcomes and monitor quality improvements over time.

RELATED READING

How Healthix Built a Scalable Data Quality Strategy

Preparing Data for AI and Advanced Analytics

As health care organizations explore artificial intelligence (AI), predictive analytics, and real-world evidence generation, data quality is becoming even more important.

Healthix is expanding its focus beyond basic completeness and conformance to evaluate whether expected information exists at the encounter level, creating a more clinically meaningful measure of quality.

SYNCRONYS is pursuing AI-assisted quality monitoring through advanced tooling and AI Quality Agents that can identify potential issues while maintaining human oversight and accountability.

Big Sky Care Connect is developing specialized quality monitoring capabilities for clinical quality measures, including HEDIS and Medicaid Core Measures.

Across these efforts, one message is clear: trusted AI requires trusted data.

7 Takeaways for Health Data Organizations Looking to Do Similar Work

  1. Start with the use case: Define what quality means for the clinical, operational, or reporting objective you're trying to achieve.
  2. Establish governance early: Sustainable improvement requires accountability, leadership support, and stakeholder engagement.
  3. Focus on high-value data elements first: Early wins help build organizational momentum.
  4. Invest in measurement and monitoring: Dashboards, scorecards, and automated assessment tools enable continuous improvement.
  5. Strengthen patient identity management: Accurate matching is foundational to data integrity.
  6. Share results transparently: Feedback loops, scorecards, and reporting create accountability and encourage improvement.
  7. Prepare for future use cases: AI, advanced analytics, quality measurement, and value-based care all depend on trusted data.
Civitas extends our sincere thanks to our members, Big Sky Care Connect, SYNCRONYS, and Healthix, for sharing their expertise and experiences to inform this case study and support learning across the Civitas Network.

Share: